- 2024 Kendal Ogles, St. John's Episcopal School
- 2023 Joanna Piris, FSUS
- 2022 Tony Haakman, St. Stephen's Episcopal School
- 2021 Kristen Kenney Youngblood, Maclay School
- 2020 Silvana Wilbur, Holy Trinity Episcopal Academy
- 2019 Generosa Sangco-Jackson, Oak Hall School
- 2018 Phil Dillinger, Berkeley Preparatory School
- 2017 Adam Mize, Holy Trinity Episcopal Academy
- 2016 Leslie Peebles, Holy Comforter Episcopal School
- 2015 Daniel Robie, Winter Springs High School
- 2014 Dr. Craig Bebergal, Florida Virtual School
- 2013 David Jackson, Oak Hall School
- 2012 Jeffrey Satriano, Maclay School
- 2011 Dr. Susan McDonald, Lakewood Ranch HS
- 2010 Ken Andino, Maclay School
- 2009 Sue Shelton, Florida Virtual School
- 2008 Catherine Sturgill, St. Francis Catholic High
- 2007 Ritchie Raulerson, Samuel W. Wolfson High
- 2006 Geoff Revard, St. Stephen's Episcopal School
- 2005 Linda Renick, Forest High
- 2004 Carol Sheber, Bishop Moore HS
- 2003 Casey Carpenter-Smith, Stanton Prep
- 2002 Hans Mueller, Florida State University
- 2002 Marie Girardeau, Fletcher High School
- 2001 Virginia Schrenker
- 2000 Amy Hornick, Escambia High School
- 1999 Doug Keller, Spruce Creek High School
- 1998 Leslie Perkins, St. John's Country Day
- 1997 Linda Mishkin, St. Stephen's Episcopal School
- 1996 Kay Ruhle, Florida Virtual School
- 1995 Lois Ann Bower, Lincoln High School
- 1994 Donna Boles
- 1993 Sara Gibson
- 1992 Justin Glenn, Florida State Univ.
- 1991 Aurelia Ogles, Leesburg High School
- 1990 Alan Blessing, Northeast High School
- 1989 Margo Hall, Leon High School
- 1988 Nancy Allen, Sandalwood High School
- 1987 Sheila Dickison, University of Florida
- 1986 Helene Kansas
- 1985 Regina Kelley, Leon High School
- 1984 Karen Lee Singh, Florida High
- 1983 Linda Gaskin, Ed White High School
- 1982 Marcia Stille, Lakeland High School
- 1981 Joe Gilpin, Bayshore High School